March 22, 2019 at 06:43AM by CWC
The Mediterranean diet garnered heaps of praise in 2019, thanks to its recent recognition as the healthiest eating plan in the world. The fact that it promotes longevity is backed by plenty of studies and it’s a relatively easy diet to follow. But a lesser-known eating plan may be coming for the Med diet’s crown. Meet the Okinawa diet.
The Mediterranean diet, of course, emphasizes healthy fats like omega-3s, protein from primarily seafood and plant sources, and lots of fruits and vegetables. The Okinawa diet, on the other hand, is plant-driven, with most nutrients (including carbs) coming from vegetables and legumes locally available on the island.
Okinawa is a Japanese island (and is the nation’s southernmost prefecture). The island is one of the original “Blue Zones,” or areas with populations known for their longevity. “The Okinawa diet gets a lot of attention because the people who live on the island have a higher than average life expectancy at 100 years old, compared to the US at 78.8 years and the rest of Japan at 84 years old,” says Nora Minno, RD. (Sounds an awful lot like the other aforementioned eating plan that might help you live longer.)
Which begs the question: How do the Okinawa and Mediterranean diets, both inspired by Blue Zones populations, compare? The short version: John Day, MD, a cardiologist and co-author of the book The Longevity Plan, says both eating plans can be good for longterm health. “You really can’t say one is better than the other as they have never been compared in a head-to-head clinical study,” he notes. “However, if you look at the populations of people adhering to these ancestral diets you will see a long-lived population mostly free of the modern diseases that plague those following the ‘standard American diet.’”
I asked Dr. Day and Minno, as well as Brigitte Zeitlin, MPH, RD, the owner of BZ Nutrition in New York City, to break down the differences between the two healthy eating plans.
1. Their protein sources are a bit different
Don’t get it twisted: “It is not a vegetarian diet, just eats less [meat] than the Mediterranean diet,” says Zeitlin. In the Mediterranean diet, omega-3-rich protein sources like fish, shellfish, and other types of seafood reign supreme, followed by vegetables and legumes (with small, occasional amounts of red meat thrown in for good measure). The Okinawa diet, on the other hand, is extremely vegetable-forward, especially with protein. “Protein comes from small amounts of fish, occasional pork, and mostly from plant-based sources such as vegetables, legumes, and tubers,” says Dr. Day. Soy is also a big component of this eating plan, adds Zeitlin.
2. Both are pro-carbs, particularly the Okinawa diet
Sorry, keto—both the Mediterranean diet and the Okinawa diet allow for pretty decent amounts of healthy carbohydrates. “Carbs have a bad rap,” says Dr. Day. “Certainly, sugar and processed carbs are going to get you in trouble. And most people consuming large amounts of sugar and processed carbs ultimately gain excessive weight and may suffer from diabetes. However, the unprocessed carbs that come from vegetables, fruit, and legumes can optimize for health and longevity.”
Specifically, the Okinawa diet involves a 10:1 ratio of carbs to protein (let THAT sink in), which researchers have consistently found is nearly identical to the optimum ratio of carbs and protein for longevity in rats and other animals. The Mediterranean diet also endorses healthy carbs from whole foods (although not as intense as that 10:1 ratio), and encourages whole grains as well as fruits, vegetables, and other plant-based carbohydrates.
3. …except only one is big on grains
If you love rice and pasta…the Okinawa diet is not for you. “This diet is very low in refined carbohydrates like white rice, bread, pasta, sweets, and baked goods,” says Zeitlin. However, it packs in lots of complex carbohydrates (remember that whole 10:1 ratio?) in the form of potatoes, squash, soybeans, and lentils, she says. The Med diet does have those complex carbs, but still allows for some simple carbs like grains, breads, and pasta.
“If people are mostly grain-free already, the Okinawa diet could be a better option for them to try,” Zeitlin says. However, the limited grains could be a tough shift for others, she says. “You will have to cut back on your oatmeal, quinoa, brown rice, and whole wheat bread,” she says, to one to two times per week. Compare that to the Mediterranean diet, which she says promotes one to two servings of grains per day.
4. Vegetables are the stars of the show for both
Unlike, say, paleo or Keto, no vegetable or fruit is off-limits on either the Mediterranean diet or the Okinawa diet. And their inclusion is central to both plans’ longevity-promising benefits. “The vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants in these varying fruits and veggies is what will promote a longer (and healthier) life,” Zeitlin says.
Minno adds that the Okinawa diet focuses on veggies that are local and easily available to the population, like purple sweet potatoes, seaweed, Goya (bitter melon), and soy beans. “The diet is also known for being rich in yellow and orange vegetables with are common sources of carotenoids, nutrients that can help reduce inflammation, support eye health, and support a healthy immune system,” she says. But again, all veggies are on the table so to speak.
5. Neither plan requires calorie-counting or restriction
Yet another point in both diets’ favor. “The beautiful thing about the Okinawa diet is the Confucian practice of hara hachi bu—meaning you eat until you’re satisfied, not full,” says Minno. “This practice brings a sense of mindfulness to eating and allows people to connect with and enjoy their food rather than rushing through a meal or overeating.” She adds that it’s hard to overeat on a diet like the Okinawa diet, which is packed with vegetables and fiber (the latter of which is super filling). “Studies do show, however, that Okinawans tend to consume fewer overall calories, approximately 20 percent less than the rest of the Japanese population.”
Similarly, the Mediterranean diet does not emphasize tracking calories or macros. It’s widely considered by experts to be permissive, unlike other eating plans.
6. Benefits-wise, both eating plans are pretty comparable
Both the Mediterranean and Okinawa diets come from Blue Zone areas that promote longevity. “Because of their emphasis on that plant-based life, both diets are high in fiber and antioxidants that help to fight chronic illnesses life diabetes, inflammation, heart disease, and certain cancers, and promote healthy skin, hair, and nails,” says Zeitlin. However, Zeitlin adds that the Okinawa diet is lower in dairy, which may help promote clearer skin if you’re acne-prone.
At the end of the day, both of these diets are pretty damn good for anyone. “Any eating plan that excludes sugar, processed carbs, and fast or fried foods can optimize for health and longevity,” says Dr. Day. “Likewise, any eating plan that maximizes vegetable intake may also optimize for health and longevity.”
Zeitlin agrees. “The key take away from both lifestyles is that they want you eating fruits and veggies, and that is the foundation of any healthy lifestyle,” she says. So whether you’re more into the specifics of the Okinawa or the Mediterranean way, you’re still on the way to a potentially longer life (with lots of health benefits to boot).
Additional reporting by Emily Laurence.